logoalt Hacker News

firesteelrainyesterday at 7:08 PM4 repliesview on HN

It’s not just the complex XML based format. Word has collaboration tie-in’s with Skype, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive etc

It’s an entire ecosystem

Also, I have tried to use LibreOffice and you have to learn an entirely new tool. The user interfaces are different. Word has its own issues of course but LibreOffice does not feel as polished

There are things in Word that are legacy and carry overs from another time that carry various nuance. It’s not all documented set of features either

Trying to replicate the entire look and feel is incredibly difficult

Most people are going to encounter Word in a corporate setting and to have them switch to another tool is going to a big hill to climb


Replies

freeopinionyesterday at 7:33 PM

I have met very few non-techies that could tell the difference between Word and Wordpad or use them any differently.

Most people below the age of 30 can switch between Google Docs or Word without blinking. They don't use more than a few of the features of either.

This "big hill" you mention is a fantasy.

show 1 reply
jasonjayryesterday at 7:24 PM

At one point LibreOffice + MS Office were pretty much on par with each other.

But MS has built this giant moat of integrated proprietary services around these systems that make it difficult to switch away once you are sucked into the environment.

It takes a pretty sizable expense to switch to anything else, while satisfying all of a companies different workflows for various roles and levels of experience.

If not MS Office + it's M365 Eco system, what then? Google Workspace? That's kinda the same problem in a different color?

show 1 reply
SoftTalkeryesterday at 7:47 PM

> I have tried to use LibreOffice and you have to learn an entirely new tool.

I use word processors so rarely that every time it's like learning a new tool. Whether it's Word, Google Doc, LibreOffice, or anything else.

I will say that Google Docs and Word both feel a bit more "polished" than LibreOffice which still feels very distinctly like a 1990's era desktop program. I guess because it is.

show 2 replies
trelaneyesterday at 7:21 PM

If LibreOffice were smart, they'd introduce free licensing for schools and universities, so the students could learn it and then ask for it when they get to jobs later on.

Maybe they could even release the source under a copyleft license, so the students can learn from it and maybe contribute.

show 1 reply