logoalt Hacker News

ulfwyesterday at 12:03 AM2 repliesview on HN

Regulating it while the cat is out of the bag leads to monopolistic conglomerates like Meta and Google. Meta shouldn't have been allowed to usurp instagram and whatsapp, Google shouldn't have been allowed to bring Youtube into the fold. Now it's too late to regulate a way out of this.


Replies

pbh101yesterday at 3:36 AM

It’s easy to say this in hindsight, though this is the first time I think I’ve seen someone say that about YouTube even though I’ve seen it about Instagram and WhatsApp a lot.

The YouTube deal was a lot earlier than Instagram, 2006. Google was way smaller than now. iPhone wasn’t announced. And it wasn’t two social networks merging.

Very hard to see how regulators could have the clairvoyance to see into this specific future and its counter-factual.

user5534762135yesterday at 9:36 AM

>Now it's too late to regulate a way out of this.

Technically untrue, monopoly busting is a kind of regulation. I wouldn't bet on it happening on any meaningful scale, given how strongly IT benefits from economies of scale, but we could be surprised.