logoalt Hacker News

elsjaakoyesterday at 9:38 AM3 repliesview on HN

Copyright is not a god given right. It's an economic incentive created by government to make desired behavior (writing an publishing books) profitable.


Replies

klabb3yesterday at 3:12 PM

Yes, 100%. And that’s why throwing copyright selectively in the bin now when there’s an ongoing massive transfer of wealth from creators to mega corps, is so surprising. It’s almost as if governments were only protecting economic interests of creators when the creators were powerful (eg movie studios), going after individuals for piracy and DRM circumvention. Now that the mega corps are the ones pirating at a scale they get a free pass through a loophole designed for individuals (fair use).

Anyway, the show must go on so were unlikely to see any reversal of this. It’s a big experiment and not necessarily anything that will benefit even the model providers themselves in the medium term. It’s clear that the ”free for all” policy on grabbing whatever data you can get is already having chilling effects. From artists and authors not publishing their works publicly, to locking down of open web with anti-scraping. Were basically entering an era of adversarial data management, with incentives to exploit others for data while protecting the data you have from others accessing it.

show 4 replies
bryanrasmussenyesterday at 5:28 PM

actually in much of the EU if not all of it Copyright is an intrinsic right of the creator.

show 1 reply
kriopsyesterday at 10:34 AM

Yes it is. In every sense of the phrase, except the literal.

show 2 replies