logoalt Hacker News

itsoktocry11/04/202511 repliesview on HN

I've been a long-time Twitter user. I don't hate Elon, so when he bought it I was cautiously optimistic.

I deactivated last week. The platform is bad and getting worse. It's scammy and spammy. Everything is designed around garbage engagement, so that the X team can brag about how good the product is doing.


Replies

HeinzStuckeIt11/04/2025

I follow a couple of writers on X through Nitter on a desktop browser. These writers inevitably draw bot comments whenever they touch on something relevant to some or another powerful country’s politics. For me, it’s easy to verify that these commentators (who often have convincing-sounding fake names and photos) are bots by simply ctrl-clicking on the commenters’ usernames and, in the tab that immediately opens, seeing at a glance that they post weird single-issue material at an unusually sporadic pace, and often in tellingly flawed English.

Do I suspect correctly that in the way most people consume X, though the official website or an app, this is not so transparent? Whether because opening new views is so slow on a phone screen, or because the official interfaces probably intersperse content with advertisements and other visual crap? I don’t think state actors would be so active in trying to manipulate discourse if the platform hadn’t degraded to a point where their activity isn’t obvious to most users.

show 1 reply
dayvid11/04/2025

It's a full PvP server now. Old Social media outrage algos + paying people for posts further broke it

show 1 reply
moduspol11/04/2025

I just use the "Following" tab (and not the "For you" tab).

vachina11/04/2025

I prefer the X now. Unlimited stream of unhinged, unfiltered thought stream from strangers straight into my feed.

show 2 replies
kjkjadksj11/04/2025

Only last week is shocking to me. People were saying this about twitter for like 10+ years as soon as it was commercialized and was no longer just user content.

alpineman11/04/2025

I am honestly curious what Elon would need to do for you to dislike him. That ship sailed for me long ago

show 3 replies
zoeysmithe11/04/2025

I mean his personal lack of ethics, bigotries, greed, and ignorance is what directly made twitter what it is today. Maybe you should dislike him and hold him in low opinion.

scottcorgan11/04/2025

[flagged]

show 1 reply
yapyap11/04/2025

[flagged]

show 1 reply
bko11/04/2025

What is garbage engagement?

I think its entirely reasonable that an algorithm shows you things that you engaged with. It would be weird if it didn't promoted stuff I didn't engage w/.

show 2 replies