logoalt Hacker News

lokaryesterday at 9:54 PM1 replyview on HN

No one would build KRB4/5 today, it makes no sense. It's only advantage over an X.509 cert based system is speed on really really slow CPUs.


Replies

jcglyesterday at 11:29 PM

That doesn't seem right to me, assuming you still want the paradigm of one-time principal-to-domain authentication with just-in-time principal-to-resource authentication. While I think you could probably use x509 certs to streamline and modernize the ticket-granting-and-session-key dance, you'd still be doing a lot of the same high-level things.

Depending on the use-case, Kerberos (/this imagined x509 Kerberos) or Oauth2 still seems suitable for single-authenticator/multiple-services paradigm.