logoalt Hacker News

andaitoday at 6:04 AM3 repliesview on HN

When I was a kid a friend asked me, "Hey, you speak three languages. Which one do you think in?"

I was bemused, and thought... "people think in words?"

Apparently people with ADHD or Autism can develop the inner voice later in life.

In my 20s, language colonized my brain. Took me years of meditation to get some peace and quiet back...


Replies

wobfantoday at 8:49 AM

I have never not thought in words. How does it work? Like, how can I for example think about plans or something if not in words?

I do meditate here and now, but sooner or later the constant stream of words will 100% set in again, usually during or immediately after meditation. And these words for example tell me or discuss whether I should go shower, go to gym, do dishes, or whatever. And in the end I'll decide based on that discussion and do it. It's weird how defined I am by this inner voice.

show 3 replies
tarsingetoday at 7:49 AM

Meditation is interesting because it made me able to not only separate thoughts from words, but also consciousness from thoughts.

It’s also consistent with our intuition that toddlers have consciousness and thoughts and other mammals at least consciousness (and emotions) without language.

alfiedotwtftoday at 9:13 AM

This feels like last year when I found out I have ADHD and aphantasia...

What do you mean "think in words"? Is it like a narrator, or a discussion like Herman's Head? Are you hearing these words all the time or only when making decisions?