logoalt Hacker News

Leak confirms OpenAI is preparing ads on ChatGPT for public roll out

403 pointsby fleahuntertoday at 11:31 AM404 commentsview on HN

Comments

CuriouslyCtoday at 1:44 PM

Literally just cancelled my pro subscription.

Towaway69today at 4:01 PM

Imagine if the Roman Empire had financed itself via advertising. What wonderful art they would have left behind. Or the Incas. Or the Egyptians.

On the other hand, with the money they would have made ... hm.

sumalamanatoday at 3:44 PM

Just deleted my ChatGPT account.

127today at 3:12 PM

Moment of truth.

ElectronShaktoday at 1:52 PM

got two new users to one of my side projects, they said they came from ChatGPT

outside1234today at 3:44 PM

Just a matter of time before they then start changing the content to pimp things.

1970-01-01today at 3:03 PM

This was more than predictable, it was the most likely outcome. Enshittified-as-a-service (eSaaS) is now the best way to make a profit in Silicon Valley. How people clearly hate it yet corporations keep getting away with it needs much more study.

precomputetoday at 3:27 PM

It will be interesting to see what their implementation is like, and if it will decrease trust in LLMs. If the ads are obvious and part of the output, then people might just socially demote chatGPT to a dumb bot.

rimmontrieutoday at 2:44 PM

It wouldn't be so bad if the ads are stuck in some dedicated regions of the chat interface. On the other hand, if it appears out of no where in the middle of the conversation, that'll be a huge turn off and terrible terrible mistake.

andrepdtoday at 3:17 PM

> Big tech claims industrial revolution-tier upheaval, AGI in 6 months, most important invention in human history

> Look inside

> Ads

idonotknowwhytoday at 3:58 PM

Just means we'll have to run another model in front of it, to filter out the ads

spacecadettoday at 2:55 PM

Ya ya everything devolves into advertising. Been saying this since ChatGPT was released. Took longer than I thought, but we are only now reaching a point where we can guarantee ROI here.

Mistletoetoday at 2:25 PM

One of the main reasons I use Google Gemini is how fast and free of ads and distractions it is. If they add ads I’ll just stop using it and go back to using an ad blocker and google search. Nothing AI does is irreplaceable for me really. I just use what is easier.

nurettintoday at 1:57 PM

I will just use the LLM I pay for to pre-filter ads from the other instance.

alistairSHtoday at 1:45 PM

So, the enshittification of AI is well under way. Ugh. Not that I’m really surprised.

DrStartuptoday at 1:13 PM

absolutely f ads

neonnoodletoday at 3:24 PM

So… AGI any day now, huh?

apitoday at 3:14 PM

Here it comes.

This is what will be remembered as the pre enshittification age for AI, just like we had with social media and other web and app stuff.

Local models for tech savvy people will get more compelling.

show 1 reply
jennyholzertoday at 2:10 PM

IMO OpenAI is the contemporary manifestation of the sort of eugenicist thought that infected and eventually haunted the United States and Europe in the 19th and 20th centuries.

I can't speak for other cultures, but as an English-language speaker, I can see plainly that OpenAI has done and is doing an effective job of homogenizing English language culture.

It offends me that ChatGPT is too conservative to analyze Shakespeare's sonnets. These works are the bedrock of English language literary culture, and ChatGPT is far, far, too heavily censored to meaningfully interpret these short, simple poems.

As an example, Sonnet 131 describes Shakespeare's sexual encounter with a dark-skinned prostitute. After he ejaculates, he reflects on the spot of his semen which has landed on her, stating "Thy black is fairest in my judgment’s place."

The point is (quite obviously), that the blob of semi-translucent semen has created a spot on the woman's skin which is a lighter tone than the rest of her body.

ChatGPT utterly fails to acknowlege this obvious literal interpretation of this poem. ChatGPT's analysis follows:

"In short. He is saying that her dark appearance—which others might criticize—is, to him, the most beautiful and desirable."

English literary culture is unique for its integration of "high" and "low" art within individual works. Restated, it is uniquely common in the English language for works to contain simultaneous expressions of "high" and "low" cultures. The relationship between Jazz (high brow) American Showtunes (low brow) may be the most relevant example of this cultural feature to a contemporary American audience.

The extension of social media content restriction policies into the arena of "AI" chatbots is radicalizing English speakers against the greatest artistic works produced using our language.

------------------------

edit: to the guy who responded to me, check out the poem!: https://shakespeareoxfordfellowship.org/wp-content/uploads/D... (#131).

The poem begins in media res, immediately before Shakespeare is about to ejaculate. He reflects on negative comments others have made about this woman's appearance:

"Yet, in good faith, some say that thee behold, Thy face hath not the power to make love groan"

in other words, others say that this lady's face is too ugly to make them cum.

Shakespeare reverses this insult in "the moment of truth" (i.e. the "money shot"):

"A thousand groans, but thinking on thy face, One on another’s neck, do witness bear Thy black is fairest in my judgment’s place. "

While Shakespeare fantasizes about her face ("thinking on thy face"), he ejaculates (read: "bears witness") on the back of her neck. This is "proof" that the lady's detractors (who said her face was too ugly to get a man off) are wrong, at least from Shakespeare's perspective.

"Thy black is fairest in my judgement's place" is the first line of the poem that occurs after Shakespeare has ejaculated. Now that he has satisfied his sexual urge, he inhabits a palpably different psychology. He reflects on the puddle of semen he has produced. The blend of colors in the puddle is evocative of the sexual union between Shakespeare and his lover.

Shakespeare is really a violent, devil-tongued, sex-crazed maniac, very similar in a lot of ways to John Lennon. It's very important to this poem that Shakespeare is crazed at the start of the poem, and is only able to calm himself by satiating his sexual urges.

The ChatGPT analysis is accurate enough, from a thematic perspective, but ChatGPT is literally not allowed to decode the literal meaning of the line-by-line text.

ChatGPT cannot and is not allowed to understand the literal meaning of this poem. It has learned the thematic interpretation by ingesting a lot of Shakespeare analysis, but it is not capable of telling you the human actions or thought processes which the poem describes.

-----

@eszed I'd urge you to read my post again more closely. You seem to struggle with close reading.

show 1 reply
rhetocj23today at 5:11 PM

[dead]

arschfickniggertoday at 2:42 PM

[flagged]

jennyholzertoday at 1:38 PM

[flagged]

show 1 reply
Madmallardtoday at 12:23 PM

RIP their stock price once that’s live

Probably can make a ton of money shorting that

show 3 replies