logoalt Hacker News

a-dubtoday at 2:39 AM1 replyview on HN

there's some ubuntu/gnome thing that replicates the worst features of the mac.

but here's the real question: why? the global menu bar is literally the most dated and outmoded element in macos. it isn't 1993 anymore. your computer can run more than one program at a time. a globally modal application focus is completely ridiculous. the only thing more ridiculous than a global menu bar is a global spinning beach ball mouse cursor. these are relics of the past and have no place in a modern, multitasking, multiprocessing, multiprocessor, multiscreen computing environment.

moreover, the things that matter, browsers and terminals, don't even have normal menus anyway.

kde plasma is superior in all ways. stop wasting time with weird outmoded 1993 era computer interfaces.


Replies

int_19htoday at 5:08 AM

Browsers and terminals have "normal menus". Some examples would include Vivaldi and iTerm.

I agree though that placing it on top of the screen (as opposed to the window to which it applies) doesn't make any sense. Windows actually got that right with MDI way back in the day, if you remember how menu merging worked there.

However, there is an unexpected upside to having the menubar there even so. Because macOS apps can't not have a menu bar, they are forced to expose their commands there. Which usually ends up being a more stable UX compared to all the moving around of buttons in the window itself, plus you can search the menus.