logoalt Hacker News

candiddevmiketoday at 3:17 PM4 repliesview on HN

What is your definition of "new person" though? If someone has been remote for years, are they still a "new person"? If you trust them enough to hire them, why is there a need to keep earning trust for more privileges. This just seems like a carrot to squeeze some kind productivity or control out of people.


Replies

Aurornistoday at 3:24 PM

New to the company. Being in-person makes it easier to build new relationships, make friends with people you wouldn’t normally run into in your corner of Slack, and pick up more info about how the company works.

> If you trust them enough to hire them, why is there a need to keep earning trust for more privileges.

In person accelerates onboarding for all the reasons I mentioned above. It’s not a game of trust or “carrots”.

jayd16today at 3:45 PM

Why have managers and reviews and non-automated promotions and security groups if you trusted them enough to hire them...

Well because obviously that trust only goes so far.

show 2 replies
zeryxtoday at 3:23 PM

I've only ever worked remote professionally and I've got a track record, when I apply to a new role there's no question that I can adapt to working remotely at X company.

If I just finished my PhD in comp sci and have never worked professionally in my life let alone remotely, going day 1 remote is a huge risk

show 1 reply
unethical_bantoday at 3:55 PM

I say that hiring someone is not an absolute vote of confidence in a person. Even if someone is a veteran worker, most companies have a new employee orientation. Having a "probation period" where someone comes into the office to integrate and meet people and work more collaboratively makes sense to me.

Disclaimer: While I benefit and often like a remote work or hybrid setup, I also know that my career and my ability to absorb new technologies has been crippled by the isolation of remote work. And, my success and my level of knowledge in my field is directly attributed to being physically around a lot of people and several related departments in order to ask questions and mingle with experts.

Remote work sucks for learning, for me - and I know I'm not alone.