logoalt Hacker News

tclancytoday at 3:45 PM1 replyview on HN

Just because people make stuff up on certain corners of the Internet doesn't mean everyone does. Occam's Razor applies here: some guy who has been in the industry 25 years doesn't have any good stories to illustrate his point (how did he reach the conclusion then?) so he makes one up, writes a whole blog post and then someone else posts it here-- what's the endgame?


Replies

throwaway150today at 5:14 PM

> what's the endgame?

Is it not obvious? The endgame is to publish a blogpost that sounds interesting. That itself may be the reward and the endgame for the author.

Someone who has worked for 25 years would definitely have stories. I've worked far longer than that. I've got stories too. But none of the stories are as ridiculous as a "coworker" thinking that of all things IntelliJ would lead to the doom of software engineering or multimedia would lead to the collapse of an industry. I mean, what the heck! How does one even go from "multimedia" to "collapse of an industry". There is no logical connection. On the other hand, "multimedia" creates more work in the industry.

So my application of Occam's Razor tells me, surely the stories are made up to set up strawman that they can take down one by one to write an interesting blog post.

But I'll reiterate that it's a good post. I can like a post and find issues with it at the same time. I find all the strawman a bit forced which detracts from the reading experience.