logoalt Hacker News

GitHub Actions was down

639 pointsby ceberttoday at 11:42 AM328 commentsview on HN

Comments

couAUIAtoday at 12:19 PM

LoL they added "Copilot AI Model Providers" in githubstatus and it has 100% up time.

Thanks for pointing out that nobody is using that thing

gib444today at 12:23 PM

List of things "DoS"d by AI:

- GitHub

- Hiring budgets

- RAM (/personal computing in general)

- Electricity

- Media/Content

- Truth

nickstinematestoday at 3:04 PM

The main operating model with git is going to go back to decentralized. Setting up and managing something like https://forgejo.org/ is a way better experience than constant interruptions by a faulty service that can't meet demand.

The open source contribution model as we once knew it is dead; you're not going to accept patches from random agents. The risk is way too high. And you can see that increasingly "AI Slop" makes it difficult to be a maintainer of any semblance of a popular repo.

So what's the value? A durable place to store work? hah.

Discovery? That part of Github has always been shitty.

So that leaves.. Github Actions? The thing that is down every other day and has been the subject of a few ~rug pulls~/attempted price hikes that are almost surely coming back?

CSMastermindtoday at 2:30 PM

Will more copilot usage fix this? We should try more copilot.

show 1 reply
shevy-javatoday at 4:03 PM

Microsoft is really working hard to kill off GitHub now. That's quite amazing.

We have already seen this in the last some weeks, but now this has become a meme that keeps on giving. GitHub down! GitHub up again. GitHub Down! GitHub ... ...

miki123211today at 3:05 PM

This is your periodic reminder that Github is growing at ~14x (1400%!) annually. This would be incredible growth for a young, unprofitable, VC-funded startup, even Uber never achieved more than ~3x AFAIK. For a widely-established company that was already very well known and a market leader in its niche for many years? Absolutely unprecedented.

This is a conservative estimate assuming linear growth, the actual number is likely going to be higher. Much higher.

It's not too hard to grow 14X YoY if you start from a hundred customers. If you have hundreds of millions? Yeah, not so easy.

[1] https://x.com/kdaigle/status/2040164759836778878

show 1 reply
ceberttoday at 12:08 PM

I think we should start betting if GitHub will be down on Polymarkets or something at this point.

show 1 reply
dbuckmantoday at 1:48 PM

I started an open source Git platform. Can be self hosted. I would call it beta at this point if you are interested in trying it. https://velogit.com

show 1 reply
saltyoldmantoday at 4:48 PM

Git is decentralized until it's used by companies.

suis_sivatoday at 4:25 PM

Not to shill myself, but I'm sick and tired of this and been sick and tired for the last month. Decided to quit my job to work on https://harmont.dev

sh-chotoday at 12:12 PM

'Degraded' should be banned in status pages. It sounds just irresponsible, like "Yeah, it can be slow or something sometime. Whatever. Who cares"

show 3 replies
hansmayertoday at 12:58 PM

No way - everyone tells me the AI adoption is going great?

mohsen1today at 12:10 PM

oh man spent so much time trying to debug what's going on. I have a complex setup with GitHub Actions and self hosted runners so I thought it's something broken in my CI setup

show 1 reply
danielojtoday at 12:45 PM

Does anyone use any good alternatives to GitHub Actions?

show 1 reply
adamddev1today at 12:48 PM

How's the AI generated code running for ya?

liamdoyletoday at 12:42 PM

Has anyone actually moved off? If so where?

I like being able to vote with my (teams) wallet and I'm tired of staying out of convenience

show 1 reply
markfsharptoday at 12:56 PM

Contingency action plan: Codeberg. Engage.

hxiitoday at 3:42 PM

At this point it's as if the team there went "fuck it, let's just watch it all burn down" or something.

With all the recent negativity – how are they not even TRYING to fix the damn thing?

carreautoday at 12:35 PM

i still can't see many pull requests in a bunch of repositories... it's been over a month

throwatdem12311today at 12:12 PM

When is it up?

show 1 reply
hmmdogtoday at 1:01 PM

Tell Claude to fix it, simple.

rock_artisttoday at 12:24 PM

Super odd make productivity useless

vitally3643today at 2:51 PM

My first time using GH Actions was last week. GH was so flaky that pulling a submodule failed >50% of the time. I had to write a script to retry pulling the submodule in a loop.

I've done some hacky shit in CI scripts, but none made me more mad than that one.

shadowbiptoday at 2:35 PM

here all is ok, 3 actions without problem

bdangubictoday at 3:11 PM

Feels like Github Actions is UP should on the front page (when it happens) at this point. Down is no longer front page worthy

Cupprumtoday at 1:02 PM

It should be up again

jamie_davenporttoday at 1:20 PM

This has become so typical that we've started working on a modern Github alternative called Plain.

Perfect timing that we post https://www.jxd.dev/writing/building-plain just as this latest incident started.

dncornholiotoday at 2:23 PM

Stop relying on Github.

Self hosted Gitlab with self hosted (or AWS) runners running your pipelines.. We only use Github as a mirror for our public repositories.

j45today at 1:55 PM

With the increasing challenges from bots and ai agents created with toddler level clarity, Self hosting is going to continue to work.

moonrailguntoday at 12:44 PM

my work is totally stop. cry

theologantoday at 1:18 PM

Zero Nines. Bogus.

booleandilemmatoday at 2:55 PM

Too many DEI hires? Or maybe H-1Bs? Or maybe it's a vibe coding problem.

show 1 reply
sylwaretoday at 12:16 PM

microsoft github should work at restoring interop with noscript/basic HTML browsers...

show 1 reply
aa-jvtoday at 12:31 PM

Too many times we've been bitten by this - it has been an issue too many times to count.

This is why we don't use Github Actions, kids.

Seriously, its a proprietary build service that puts the keys to the kingdom in someone elses' control. Just: No!

Print this status page to PDF so you've got it handy next time someone castigates you for not using Github Actions, folks.

show 1 reply
rvztoday at 12:11 PM

Another outage at GitHub with actions and pages not working thanks to the AI agents Copilot and Tay.ai creating more issues. Last time this happened was 6 days ago. [0]

This time today it was caused by friendly fire by the automatic suspension of the GitHub Actions bot which is now a "Ghost" user. Since there is no CEO of GitHub to contact it we are just going to see more [1] of this again.

You might need to push a critical change soon, but now you cannot. You won't get any of these issues if you self hosted as I said 6 years ago...[2]

[0] https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/g6ffrm0rfvz9

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48085501

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867803

dijittoday at 2:41 PM

[dead]

Simon_Fengtoday at 3:20 PM

[dead]

viveksingh_17today at 4:53 PM

[flagged]

swordlucky666today at 4:26 PM

[dead]

galaxdbtoday at 12:34 PM

[flagged]

TestUser00today at 12:52 PM

lol

hk1337today at 12:48 PM

https://github.blog/changelog/2026-05-15-github-app-installa...

I'm guessing related to this? The blog post is dated 11 days ago but I just noticed a blue banner on my actions page today.