logoalt Hacker News

AWS: Inaccurate Estimated Billing Data – $1.7 billion

996 pointsby nprateemyesterday at 9:42 AM620 commentsview on HN

URL already posted: https://health.aws.amazon.com/health/status

I've got an estimated bill for $1.7 BILLION over this month. Normal usage is < $5.

Obvs have created an urgent AWS support ticket. Anyone else seeing something like this?

Update: Reddit link: https://www.reddit.com/r/aws/comments/1uyuaw7/help_my_bill_s...


Comments

lordleftyesterday at 12:47 PM

Got a message that I owe 37 million on an account that I haven't used in probably...6 years?

bknight1983yesterday at 11:33 AM

I'm disappointed I only got a bill for $28M, need to work harder on burning money. Seriously though I thought my life flashed before me

show 2 replies
luciana1uyesterday at 5:54 PM

at $1.7 billion, that unit conversion error is now the most expensive TODO comment in software history

eek2121yesterday at 9:35 PM

I saw another post on reddit with something like a hundred trillion dollar bill. I wish I had saved that link to share it, the comments were quite comical!

atmosxyesterday at 12:03 PM

Looks like you are the biggest shareholder. Well, going by the popular saying: “You own AWS now”.

bentobeanyesterday at 4:17 PM

Lucky. I’m on the hook for 54 billion (and change).

anibal-sanchezyesterday at 3:03 PM

The new data centers are more expensive:

ACTUAL Amount: $1,046,294,123,330.95

ryanschaeferyesterday at 2:28 PM

The market *hates* this one weird trick to juice earnings

ricketteyesterday at 12:00 PM

Some guy named Claude screwed up.

rootsuyesterday at 2:22 PM

Our org account's bill is showing up as > 100 trillion.

show 1 reply
Avicebronyesterday at 2:33 PM

Nothing like generational debt to kick off a Friday morning

show 1 reply
kvcmyesterday at 12:27 PM

I had Hermes managing mine, and it made a partial prepayment to help smooth out the bump in my account balance. Unfortunately Billing Support say my $17.4B refund may take up to 10 calendar days to be processed.

lilerjeeyesterday at 4:41 PM

It looks like AI is completely done.

hypferyesterday at 2:42 PM

To be exactly that guy:

This cannot happen if you do not do this renting at variable rates.

A thing you own doesn't suddenly bill you trillions of dollars in error. It doesn't hyperscale either, but neither do you.

fantasizryesterday at 4:18 PM

it seems like these types of problems have gained frequency in the ai era, or is it just recency bias?

thisisauseridyesterday at 11:44 AM

FinSlops.

ohnooooooooooyesterday at 12:48 PM

Did it recover for you folks? I still see billions of dollars!

shobhitguptayesterday at 3:07 PM

Have even seen a $9.2 trillion for a friend.

xyz7786yesterday at 1:44 PM

$250 billion. Nearly died right then and there

roosgityesterday at 11:02 AM

Amazon, the first quadrillion-dollar company.

swahyesterday at 5:04 PM

I prefer to just pay...

fathermarzyesterday at 11:44 AM

Just got mine. $534,366,582,647.75

show 1 reply
tonymetyesterday at 7:35 PM

I hope you have auto pay disabled

drakmoyesterday at 4:41 PM

yeah the AI read billionaring instead of billing

segmondyyesterday at 2:57 PM

vibe coding for the win.

rvzyesterday at 10:13 AM

I expect such incidents like this to continue. So please keep vibe coding.

jdw64yesterday at 1:39 PM

I almost had a heart attack because of this. I was like, did I mess up my API management? Why didn't I just use Lightsail? Those were the thoughts running through my head.

My personal website is on Lightsail, but those alerts started popping up from some test services I had set up while I was studying AI. I swear my heart nearly stopped and I cried. I really think AWS should have spending limits in place.

My bank account barely has enough for next month's rent.

orbaskeryesterday at 3:15 PM

Yes seeing the same, so far no response from AWS support

Executoryesterday at 1:24 PM

This generation is too entitled! He should some learn responsibility by paying the full amount; otherwise Amazon should delete his services/data. Consequences!

marioptyesterday at 3:11 PM

VibeBilling, love it

gomidyesterday at 12:28 PM

Curious if it's just s3 costs or other services as well?

show 1 reply
balintpeteryesterday at 9:46 AM

Yea, same here. $420M+ bill, when we have <10$ per month usually.

elzbardicoyesterday at 6:20 PM

Just got a call from the IMF president begging me to not default my debt with Amazon and offering me credit line and a plan to re-structure my debt so I don't create a global financial crisis with my default.

realizeryesterday at 10:24 AM

$627,487,837,871.49

I might be a winner.

hopppyesterday at 12:01 PM

How much is that in kidneys?

show 1 reply
ohnooooooooooyesterday at 3:37 PM

do you see cost ever day for the month of July or just the last day? I also have billions of dollars in cost explorer

phplovesongyesterday at 5:55 PM

Vibe coded fix, resulted in many having multi billion bills. Claude really did it this time.

victorbjorklundyesterday at 5:18 PM

Wild.

infamouscowyesterday at 4:55 PM

The charge-back penalties are going to be hilarious and hopefully bankrupting.

dlev_pikayesterday at 4:53 PM

> $5,544,640,717,404.09

This is what we received this morning

6stringmercyesterday at 4:37 PM

Thanks for sharing.

I’m currently dealing with Verizon Wireless and their “Jabronibot” claiming I have a fictional account balance due. It has been sent to collections, but still is being asked for by their legacy system.

The case studies of “Agents in Billing Departments” and potential shareholder lawsuits / E&O claims / reputational damage will be interesting to me. I worked in “risk management” products years ago and this kind of liability is not easily dollar traded away via contract. Will accountability stick to the Decision Makers or will they try to surrogate to the Service Providers? Hmm.

kinkurajyesterday at 11:17 AM

Yes I received an 2.8m USD budget alert.

josefritzishereyesterday at 4:14 PM

I think I know how Bezos plans to pay for his Billion dollar AI costs.

bryan_wyesterday at 4:09 PM

In an .md file somewhere:

"NEVER represent currency with floating point, multiply by 100 and store in an int before doing any math"

th3o6a1dyesterday at 11:52 AM

131 billion for me

bdangubicyesterday at 3:52 PM

I just invested ALL my money into AMZN cause next earnings report will be FIRE :)

jameskiltonyesterday at 12:31 PM

My personal photo backup S3 account, with a budget limit of $10, now going to cost me ....

$1,299,988,247,332.56!

That was a fun set of emails to wake up to, figured they had to be phishing for how outrageous of a number it was. But nope! Fun little incident they've got going over there.

tamimioyesterday at 3:32 PM

Results of vibe coding and vibe configurations.

tgvyesterday at 11:42 AM

Mine was a mere $49B. Fucking idiots.

show 1 reply
anon49584yesterday at 3:54 PM

Imagine the chaos if, as people sometimes suggest should happen, AWS shut down running instances in accounts that exceeded a billing threshold..

🔗 View 45 more comments