logoalt Hacker News

I'll never buy Framework hardware again

662 points • by unchar1 • today at 4:06 PM • 429 comments • view on HN

Comments

xp84 • today at 5:34 PM

Even though I'm rooting for Framework in their battle for repairability and upgradability versus the rest of the market which is obsessed with thinness and soldering and gluing everything... I have to acknowledge he's right to say "to hell with this company" after all that BS.

We've all seen the XKCD where a magic phrase gets you booted to a real engineer who can understand technology, instead of these script-readers who lack even the most basic computer knowledge.

You'd think that as a company which exclusively markets itself to and caters to major tech enthusiasts, Framework would have some kind of formal policy to detect when the end user calling has moderate-to-heavy troubleshooting skills and handles the situation with a reasonable process, as opposed to the treatment he got, which was basically just like dealing with Tier 1 support at HP or something, where they just walk you through rebooting or restoring the software, until you give up and throw the laptop in the trash.

Especially in the end: Clearly they sent the laptop to a place where a minimum-wage lackey opened it up, plugged it in, stuck in a USB key and ran a memory test, disk test, flash all the pixels on the screen, maybe tested the ports, and tested the keyboard in a primitive tool that amounts to a text field, by typing 1234567890 and qwertyuiop. Maybe he even swept his finger across all the keys, but that forward-delete wouldn't have been detectable.

If there were notes on the case for that person to see (and if they were competent enough to understand them), thanks to those script-readers they'd have probably seen 79 email messages, each with quoted previous messages crapping up the thread, and most of them consisting of irrelevant photographs, and they never saw what the specific problem was. So they probably just noped out of 2 hours of reading that dreck and just did a basic, generic test.

It sounds like they decided to scale their support to work like the big mainstream vendors. Odd choice.

orblivion • today at 4:41 PM

Okay so which one is the good company then? Seems like every option sucks for one reason or another.

artemonster • today at 4:38 PM

the dream of open repairable hardware is dead

➕ show 2 replies
Uptrenda • today at 6:28 PM

It's not just Framework that sucks. It's 2026 and I'm convinced there aren't any good laptops any more. It seems to me that the laptop format is built to be fragile, disposable, e-waste, similar to smart phones. So that they break in a few years or need to be "upgraded" because they become slow.

I can't tell you how many laptops that have broken for me now. I have a stack of just broken laptops in my closet (that I'll definitely fix one day... yeah) All from different brands. They've broken by having terrible fan design, USB-C ports that break, internal batteries that need replacing, power surges that have fried GPUs and other assorted faults.

Yeah, I've tried ThinkPads but modern ThinkPads are now super thin crap like any other laptop and old "refurbished" ThinkPads are on their way out. Then I have my desktop and it just quietly works, year after year. It's a Dell Workstation. Case is already perfectly organised, everything you need neatly inside. Plenty of RAM and CPU, can easily be upgraded. Cooling isn't ideal but at least its easy to maintain.

When my current laptop breaks I don't know if I'll ever buy a laptop again. It's just like... how many times do I want to make the same mistake. I don't think people should have to buy new machines every few years. I also believe the same with phones. But all this tech is designed to be disposable. They want things to fail, get slow, and need upgrades every few years. It's the same shit with every brand.

ragall • today at 4:38 PM

Too bad it's completely LLM-written.

lowbloodsugar • today at 6:02 PM

Buy on credit card. Charge back for shit like this.

jgon • today at 5:38 PM

I didn't make a post to complain back in the day because I generally support the mission of framework, but I initially ordered a framework 13 from them a few years ago. It arrived with a broken display. I spent probably 2 weeks emailing back and forth with support, re-seating display cables, formatting the machine, taking more photos and sending more emails. I had an epiphany one evening where I was bent over the open shell of the laptop with my phone out taking video. "I sent these people two thousand dollars and they sent me a machine that doesn't work, and I'm spending my evenings trying to convince them to fix it". My next email said that I wanted to take advantage of the 30 day refund period and would be sending the machine back. Suddenly support was immediately willing to send me a new display! I thought about it, and maybe that would have made everything work, but I was so fed up at that point that I said no, just give me my money back. I took that refund and immediately bought a system76 machine. Its plasticky, cheap feeling, and the fan goes crazy (although that got much better like 18 months later with the full pop_os release), but it fucking worked on day 1, and continues to work to this day.

Really the biggest thing to come out of this whole odyssey is to convince me just how good macbooks truly are, as I look over at my wife's silent behemoth of aluminum as it rips through things probably at 2x the speed while getting 3x the battery life for 1.2x more money. But I'm a fool who's still romantic about linux and supporting smaller firms and open source, so I make do. I had hoped that framework would have improved and that my experience was just early growing pains from a young company, and maybe my next machine would be from them, everyone deserves a second chance! So its pretty disappointing to see that things are still this way years later.

BoingBoomTschak • today at 5:08 PM

(Seeing https://poolp.org/ after a curious click) Man, for your own sake, remove or do something about the slop article pictures that make LinkedIn look like a bastion of taste.

dtj1123 • today at 4:36 PM

Eh. I'm still buying one.

reedlaw • today at 5:15 PM

[flagged]

danielktdoranie • today at 6:14 PM

[dead]

nsoam • today at 4:51 PM

Why did you spend 3000 euros on a laptop that isn’t from Apple? I would argue that this was all your fault.

jon128 • today at 4:43 PM

Framework's repair center ran complete diagnostics, tested two keyboards, and found that those two keyboards were working perfectly.

All these guys had to do was order a new keyboard. If they demanded a refund for the not-working keyboard they'd get one. I know, from experience having handled dozens of Framework laptops, Framework absolutely will do this.

You'd think someone offering consulting services would be a bit sharper..

The criticisms of the ticket ownership posture are helpful (depending on how accurate they actually are), I have forwarded this along to someone high up in Framework's support branch of its org chart I have a good connection with.

➕ show 1 reply
canadiantim • today at 5:12 PM

Yeah Framework is hot trash