logoalt Hacker News

yojo10/01/20246 repliesview on HN

I think it’s reasonable to expect that one of Firefox’s most popular extension publishers gets a higher tier of review service. Gorhill (and other top extension devs) are providing real value to Firefox, and have demonstrated good behavior for years.

This doesn’t mean they should get to publish whatever they want, but if a reviewer is about to reject a high profile plugin, they should get a second set of eyes on it. Which would have obviously caught the mistake here.

Feels like another “Firefox is underinvested in developer relations” story, which is surprising given how much they rely on them.

Edit: honestly the idea that gorhill doesn’t have a dedicated rep at Mozilla is baffling to me. According to their stats the extension has 8.4 million users. They should call him on the phone to let him know there’s a problem with his extension.


Replies

xnx10/01/2024

Firefox is a thick wrapper around the core functionality of uBlock on Android. Without uBlock, the case for using Firefox is very weak.

show 2 replies
munch11710/01/2024

But this is not about a high profile plugin. The high profile plugin is "uBlock Origin", and this is about "uBlock Origin Lite", which is a big thing for Chrome, but not for Firefox. Why would anyone want to use uBOL, when they have the option to use uBO?

Perhaps Mozilla does have a higher tier of review, but it's for specific plugins, not for specific authors.

show 6 replies
guilhas10/01/2024

Good point, they should be on the phone "Mr G how can our developers help you getting this extension approved"

This developer one of the main reasons for many people to use Firefox, especially in this current chrome controversy manifestV2 vs V3

And ironically this uBOL success should be of very interest to Mozilla because if it had gained more success than the main one uBO then it would be one less reason for the company to invest resources into maintaining manifestV2

SergeAx10/01/2024

uBlock Origin is THE reason I am using Firefox Mobile. The moment it gone - there's no sense in keeping the browser.

show 1 reply
causi10/01/2024

Yeah they've repeatedly used his name in advertising Firefox Mobile.