logoalt Hacker News

TeaBrain10/01/20241 replyview on HN

>Maybe having their artifacts back

The idea that modern Egyptians have any claim over the artifacts when they don't share a culture or civilization with those who created the artifacts is tenuous. The artifacts don't belong to the land itself. They belonged to people of a no longer existing civilization that once inhabited the land.


Replies

mikrl10/04/2024

Consider this though.

In the case of Britain, they got the artifacts because they established a protectorate over Egypt and thus were able to excavate and do civil engineering.

However, the fact that the artifacts were there to be discovered in the first place was because the Arab and later Ottoman overlords left them there.

So who should rightfully claim them? One of the historical suzerains of Egypt? Or the current nation of Egypt who inhabit the ancient Egyptian territory?

I can’t think of the ‘right’ (ie just) answer to that question… only practical ones.