logoalt Hacker News

RandomCitizen1210/01/20244 repliesview on HN

How can it be called a 'capture' when it's already known when and how it will leave. That's like calling a resort vacation stay a kidnapping.


Replies

enragedcacti10/01/2024

I had the same confusion so here's my layman's understanding. They are defining capture/orbit as having negative "geocentric energy" which is a term of art no one else seems to use but I think is just a mathematical representation of the following:

> a temporary satellite is any body that enters the Hill sphere of a planet at a sufficiently low velocity such that it becomes gravitationally bound to the planet for some period of time. [1]

again stretching my understanding too far, I think this basically means that in the absence of other celestial bodies the satellite would be in a stable orbit, but that in reality after some time it gets far enough away that the sun's gravitational pull dominates and stops it from making a full orbit.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporary_satellite

show 1 reply
pengaru10/01/2024

Technically The Moon is slowly leaving earth's orbit too, to the tune of 38mm per year[0]. Everything's temporary...

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbit_of_the_Moon

show 4 replies
bongodongobob10/01/2024

Because during that time from its frame of reference it will be falling around the earth until it reaches escape velocity and starts falling around the sun again.

hansvm10/01/2024

To be fair, it's still kidnapping in most states even if the duration is very short.