logoalt Hacker News

EMIRELADERO10/01/20244 repliesview on HN

What's wrong with getting money out of a product? The fact that it was an emulator changes nothing. They would have been sued, Patreon or no Patreon. Making an emulator is not illegal. And I don't mean gray-area not illegal, I mean court-precedent not illegal.


Replies

ferbivore10/01/2024

Does the Nintendo-Tropic Haze settlement not count as court precedent? It was signed off by a judge after all.

show 1 reply
gjsman-100010/01/2024

> court-precedent not illegal

Under precedents established before the DMCA was law, and under lawsuits filed before the DMCA was applicable, on consoles which did not have encryption on which the DMCA would have applied.

show 1 reply
squigz10/02/2024

Just curious, why does Nintendo seem to think they have a legal standing? Why did the Ryujinx devs give up instead of continuing their extremely-legal work?

show 1 reply
croes10/01/2024

>they took money to help people pirate a brand new game

That is where they went wrong