logoalt Hacker News

altruios10/01/20242 repliesview on HN

I can run legally an mp3 through a calculator. No one can dictate otherwise - it's my machine, and purchased media to do with as I (privately) please. This does not interfere with copyright. To legislate otherwise would be insane - as that would effectively legislate your ability to calculate.

This argument extends to any purchased media, to any program.


Replies

wilsonnb310/01/2024

If your mp3 is copy protected and your calculator bypasses that copy protection, it is in fact illegal (in the US)

show 2 replies
karmajunkie10/01/2024

unless i’m mistaken, nobody is telling you what to do with your media.

the issue at play here would be whether the emulator publishers/developers have the right to publish what is almost certainly an infringing piece of software, which courts have repeatedly determined they do not.

show 1 reply