logoalt Hacker News

causal10/01/20241 replyview on HN

You're over-anthropomorphizing. The ability of a thing to appear human says nothing of sentience.


Replies

altruios10/01/2024

like I said, I don't think this is relevant now.

We don't know what sentience IS exactly, as we have a hard time defining it. We assume other people are sentient because of the ways they act. We make a judgment based on behavior, not some internal state we can measure.

And if it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck... since we don't exactly know what the duck is in this case: maybe we should be asking these questions of 'duckhood' sooner rather than later.

So if it looks like a human, talks like a human... maybe we consider that question... and the moral consequences of owning such a thing-like-a-human sooner rather than later.

show 1 reply