logoalt Hacker News

Brian_K_White10/01/20242 repliesview on HN

Explaining that emulators can be used in concert with copyright infringement does not explain what right a copyright holder has over emulators.

That merely explains why Nintendo doesn't like them, not why anyone should care that they don't like them.

Cars may be used to commit bank robberies, yet banks have no rights over cars.


Replies

wilsonnb310/01/2024

> That merely explains why Nintendo doesn't like them, not why anyone should care that they don't like them

I don't think it has been tested in courts yet but the general idea is that you have to violate the DMCA to use a switch emulator, so people making switch emulators are making tools to help people circumvent the switch's copy protection.

Which is also a violation of the DMCA.

Like I said, it is nuanced.

consteval10/02/2024

It's more nuanced than this, because we need to acknowledge the real world and how those products are actually used.

> Cars may be used to commit bank robberies, yet banks have no rights over cars

Sure, but if said car had specific bank-robbing help built in, like say some magic device that immediately opens a bank safe, then the bank probably could sue.