logoalt Hacker News

NeoTar10/02/20241 replyview on HN

It's normalising for different things.

If you normalise for the the same ratio of cement / water / gravel / sand then sharp-sand (crushed rocks) is stronger.

If you normalise for workability (i.e. the concrete flows and can be worked easily) you need to add additional water to sharp-sand, which means that the smooth-sand (e.g. river-rocks) end up stronger.


Replies

dyauspitr10/02/2024

That’s what I mean, he doesn’t really test for absolute strength. Which one is stronger if the right amount of water for the corresponding concrete is added?