logoalt Hacker News

tombert10/10/202410 repliesview on HN

Fandom is one of my least favorite things now. The site ends up having more ads than the average porn or piracy website, it manages to slow down my relatively beefy laptops without even trying.

I love the idea of fan wikis, but Fandom is basically the worst possible implementation of that idea.


Replies

fenomas10/10/2024

Just a week or two ago my chrome plugins got temporarily disabled for some reason, and I didn't notice for a day or two... until I happened to check a fandom wiki. Then for about five seconds I thought I'd somehow installed All The Viruses.

And ironically, I already hated fandom before I'd seen it without an ad blocker! Just for the large sidebars and ugly flyouts and whatnot. It really feels like a contender for worst site on the internet.

show 1 reply
duxup10/10/2024

It's not even accurate at times. I think a lot of the dedicated fans have given up on it. I've seen several that have chunks of straight wrong information.

Usually it's stuff where the fan seems to have picked up on something implied in a story, but missed where it is clearly stated that isn't the case ... but then they go and write on fandom and make lots of assumptions from there and fill in other gaps with guesses.

show 5 replies
formerly_proven10/10/2024

In a nutshell

https://en.uesp.net/wiki/Main_Page

vs

https://elderscrolls.fandom.com/wiki/The_Elder_Scrolls_Wiki

(Though UESP has had banner ads for a while now)

show 2 replies
Dwedit10/10/2024

Fandom is perfectly usable with adblockers and the "Cleaner Fandom" userscript. But only with those extensions!

show 2 replies
ykonstant10/10/2024

I have blocked the domain on my browser; this helps with mindless clicking on fandom sites appearing on top of Google searches while the communities have moved on to other wikis.

jagermo10/10/2024

agreed. the good thing is, it teaches a new generation why adblockers are great.

GJim10/10/2024

What are these 'ads' of which you speak?

show 1 reply
dvngnt_10/10/2024

laughs in ublock origin

show 2 replies
cbm-vic-2010/10/2024

The "fan" in "Fandom" means the fan in your computer.

show 3 replies