logoalt Hacker News

rightbyte10/10/20242 repliesview on HN

How so? Fandom seems to have Google ads. We wouldn't be able to prove if Google ranked sites with their ads higher. Google's search ranking is black box. Edit: I guess at great effort you could scrape thousands of sites, not if they remove or add Google ads, and track their rating.

I think it is a better assumption to make, that Google puts their profit above luser experience, when it comes to search ranking.


Replies

niam10/10/2024

> We wouldn't be able to prove if Google ranked sites with their ads higher

This to me is a different argument, though admittedly reasonable to arrive at through the language of "paying Google for placement".

> I think it is a better assumption to make, that Google puts their profit above luser experience, when it comes to search ranking.

I mean, yes. Though I should hope I needn't preamble any statement about <company> with how cynical I am about their intentions... It's not relevant here because I'm not arguing on the grounds that 'Google would be ethical and kawaii if they didn't accept payment for organic search ranking'--I'm saying that from a business standpoint it wouldn't make sense.

show 1 reply