logoalt Hacker News

thimabi10/11/20242 repliesview on HN

As the name says, customary international law is not written. It arises from international practices that have become so widespread that states begin to recognize they have a legal obligation to continue them (opinio juris).

Current literature says that the non-usage of nuclear weapons has become a widespread international practice, but that the resistance of nuclear powers has prevented the formation of an “opinio juris” thus far. What is at stake is whether an international custom can be formed despite the opposition of certain states — as long as several other states acknowledge the custom.


Replies

exmadscientist10/11/2024

Doesn't the history of war in the twentieth century (because we've got to start somewhere) suggest that "international law" means absolutely fucking nothing at fucking all when it comes to major wars?

Why bother?

What are you going to do to enforce it, invade the guy who just nuked/invaded you/your friends?

gus_massa10/11/2024

But the several other states must have nuclear weapons to enforce the custom on a rogue country with nuclear weapons.