logoalt Hacker News

randomdata10/11/20242 repliesview on HN

When was the last time you saw profitability increase, even remain stagnant, when demand declined?

Let's be real. If demand for meat declines, producers will have to double down on "factories" in order to remain solvent.


Replies

dghlsakjg10/11/2024

Anecdotally, I disagree.

I went through a period of vegetarianism (for health reasons, not directly for ethics), and once I started eating meat again, 1. I eat a lot less, which 2. means that I can be much more intentional about sourcing it.

Right now the bulk of the meat that I eat at home throughout the year comes from 1 or 2 animals that are locally sourced and butchered (normally I share a portion of a pig and a cow), and the occasional wild caught fish. The meat is tastier, and I can go see the actual animals at the farm if I so choose. They are not factory farmed, and the price per pound is about the same as buying industrial meat at the grocery store since I am buying directly from the farmer, and paying a local processor for their services.

As things wane in popularity it might be true that they become more of a commodity, or it might be true that they become more of a niche product where people care more.

I would like to think that if meat consumption becomes more of a treat than an everyday thing, that people would treat it as such, and go out of their way to eat something that tastes better.

Food for thought?

exitb10/11/2024

Yes, I agree. As I said, that entire argument is far fetched at a few different points, this being one of them.