logoalt Hacker News

sph10/11/20242 repliesview on HN

What do you eat? I bet $10 either it's calorie-counted standard high carb diet or something that is low in protein and fats.

The physiology of dieting, and avoiding hunger, is pretty well understood at this point. Just don't ask your GP or they'll just tell you to stop eating red meat and eat more cereals as the "solution".


Replies

esfandia10/11/2024

Not the OP but I have tried to reduce my sugar intake, I'm walking more than before, and I still basically gain half a pound every year. I'd lose some weight for a few days, and gain it all back on the one day I'm a bad boy. It seems like there's an internal dial that decides what my weight is supposed to be, no matter how much I fight it. And the dial adds half a pound every year. I guess the dial is my metabolism as I age.

pixl9710/11/2024

Eh, in a clinical setting only eating "good food" works fine.

In the real world this is not what people experience. Especially those that experience mental food noise.

Imagine there is a donut in a box at work. It's free, you can have it at any point. It's junk food, it's bad for you, it's not part of your diet and you don't want it. I mean you ate a high fiber food and protein earlier, you shouldn't be hungry at all. Now imagine there's an additional voice in your head that just slips in "Ok, finish that page your on and go pick up that donut". How long can you resist it? You probably won't even notice it since it's the normal stream of thought you have. At some point you'll end up with that donut in your hand.

Now take a GLP-1. The voice gets silenced. If you smoke or drink you'll notice that you don't really want to do that either.