logoalt Hacker News

stevenAthompson10/11/20241 replyview on HN

>That's how all creatures in the wild do it... Wait, no, it isn't.

Neither creatures in the wild, or primitive man, have access to unlimited quantities of calorie dense foods. We could go back to that lifestyle, but billions would have to die and the overall human lifespan would decrease rather than increasing.

I think I'd rather take a perfectly safe drug than go back to wiping with leaves and hunting for worm riddled meat.

> How much does that lifestyle sound like freedom to you?

I'm not even sure I understand which lifestyle you're asking about here, but if you mean the modern lifestyle then it's certainly more free than the lives primitive man had. "Might makes right" was the rule of the land back then, and contrary to your imagination, you probably wouldn't have been the mightiest. Certainly not forever.

Hell, it's more free now than the lives most of our grandparents had. 50 years ago about half of all white people surveyed said they'd move away if a black person bought a house in their neighborhood, and gay people were routinely murdered for existing.

There were no "good old days", and Stardew Valley is just a game.


Replies

jodrellblank10/12/2024

> "Neither creatures in the wild, or primitive man, have access to unlimited quantities of calorie dense foods."

And just like that, you've come up with another way.

> "I think I'd rather take a perfectly safe drug than go back to wiping with leaves and hunting for worm riddled meat."

That is some ridiculously hyperbolic panicked scaremongering at the idea of banning Coca Cola. I have literally no idea how restricting the unlimited calorie dense foods available would lead to hating black people and murdering gay people, but it's some more hyperbolic commentary.

> "I'm not even sure I understand which lifestyle you're asking about here"

The one I mentioned. Comparing the "free" lifestyle where you have adverts for Coca-Cola shoved into your face 24/7 along with adverts selling you a drug to help you ignore the Coca-Cola adverts. Vs. "non-free" where Coca-Cola isn't available for sale and you just don't think about it because you've never had it and don't miss it, and you go about your life doing the things you care about instead.

show 1 reply