logoalt Hacker News

unethical_ban10/12/20243 repliesview on HN

If someone has a broken leg, the word "crutch" isn't derogatory in the first place.

Cessation tools are not negative. Yes, root causes of abuse should be addressed, but aids are aids.


Replies

CydeWeys10/12/2024

    Crutch (n)
    a : a support typically fitting under the armpit for use by the disabled in walking
    b : a source or means of support or assistance that is relied on heavily or excessively
Use a is a neutral, non-judgmental, literal use of the word. Use b is clearly a pejorative, judgmental, metaphorical use of the word. The two are not the same.
show 2 replies
borski10/12/2024

The negative connotation of a crutch implies that you are past the point of needing it and should be standing on your own two feet. If a thing is not meant to be temporary, or if you'll never be able to perform a task as well without it as you could with it, then it's a tool rather than a crutch.

Thus, calling GLP-1 meds a “crutch” implies that they are unnecessary, and that the patient should be able to do it without medication, which then creates guilt and shame where there shouldn’t be any.

fknorangesite10/12/2024

> If someone has a broken leg, the word "crutch" isn't derogatory in the first place.

It is so profoundly disingenuous to pretend not to know what the word "crutch" means or what connotations it has in this context. Like, come on.