logoalt Hacker News

Ferret744610/12/20241 replyview on HN

This is just wrong. "Mere usage" of a software does indeed need a license, just like "mere playback" of video requires a license. Remember all of the FBI warnings on movies warning you that you can't play the video publicly?

Running software without a license is literally illegal (at least in the US). Now, whether that is enforced, and to what extent in practice is a different story, just like how piracy in general is not really enforced against.


Replies

EMIRELADERO10/12/2024

The FBI warnings are about public playback and illegal copying, both of which are explicitly outlawed by copyright law itself.

Mere execution and usage of software is simply not something copyright law cares about, which is why your assertion that

> Running software without a license is literally illegal (at least in the US).

is wrong. There is nothing in the law that gives copyright owners an exclusive right to "usage", only to the making of new copies, their distribution, derivative works, public performance, etc.