What is actually the usecase for "quantum internet"?
Like at most i hear about quantum key distribution, but quite frankly the classical equivalents to that are just as good if not better, so what is the actual benefit?
I don't know about use case but in various distributed computing models there are problems that are provably easier for quantum computers. Unlike the classical setting where the best we have is factoring where we don't know an efficient deterministic algorithm and various problems which experimentally seem to be faster for QC (and those results often don't last long as we get better at simulating quantum algorithms classically)
(1) distributed computation. If you can network two quantum computers, you essentially have one quantum computer with twice the storage. Quantum networks avoid the need to build one enormous quantum computer.
(2) easier experiments. Currently, doing a loophole free Bell inequality test is hard enough that people get PhDs for it. With a quantum network that experiment is way easier, because the network solves the hard part (distributing the entanglement). You could probably also use quantum networks for other experimental tasks, like coherently linking telescopes on separate continents, though the bandwidth and computational requirements for that would probably be a bit insane.
There are also some more out there ideas, like if stock markets contain Bell inequalities then you could use a quantum network to build up entanglement that is then consumed to win those games more often which equals $$$. But it's hard to imagine concrete scenarios that would create such an inequality, nevermind one where the expected dollars gained from the quantum strategy exceeded the cost of operating the network.
As I understand, quantum key distribution cannot be beaten by classical equivalents and they're only good or better because our current quantum computers kinda suck. So the major use case at the moment is proving the tech and developing the infrastructure. The "killer app" of the quantum internet in my mind is as simple as just sending qbits around. Currently every network call involves an observation that collapses the system wavefunction. If you're looking to actually network quantum devices (say, to run distributed quantum computations) then you need quantum infrastructure.
I'm curious too! I'd immediately understand if it allows for speed of light communication wireless, but this is clearly wired, requiring more precision engineering than usual fibre.
There is no obvious benefit yet, they are just researching for the sake of it.
I think over time they will discover a benefit but the hype is obviously not warranted.
Safer mechanisms of distributing and establishing "root" keys for identify verification (so you can then use them easier with normal D-H on normal internet) is one use case I recall from 1990s.
But few years ago I heard of some other interesting uses where quantum properties were used to essentially enable DWDM-like virtual circuit routing with higher capacity - though I would have to look again if it went anywhere or into scrap heap of quantum BS.
isn't it too early to try to draw a bottom line for this type of research?
from my perspective this is fascinating area of physics that we need to know more about and will improve our understanding of fundamental physics.
I'd prefer @ziofill to answer, but I think:
- security - if we use quantum entanglement/teleportation to the extent I've read about how it works, then even if you still need a fiber optic cable connecting the two parties, the data is unreadable if you're not looking at physically the same wave/photons, meaning that man in the middle attack (like the ones with bending an optic cable to break it's internal reflection) is literally impossible. The data in the middle would not be readable without the receiving end entangled device, and the other side would immediately know about the attack, because an identical signal would not be readable either, as it's not the same signal anymore.
- I think the ultimate promise is transferring data without a physical link of any kind in-between. Connect two atoms, manipulate one, read the other - like ansibles in LeGuin/O.S.Card fiction. Instant interplanetary communication (which, I think, fucks up the idea of time too?)
A quantum internet is absolutely necessary for creating a useful quantum computer, the same way the internet (LAN) is needed to create a supercomputer. A supercomputer is essentially many computers connected together. A quantum computer that solves problems we care about will be similar: https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10609.