logoalt Hacker News

randomdata11/07/20241 replyview on HN

> Variation of the same question: Were there radio waves before there radios?

I'm not sure that is analogous. The chicken/egg question is about at what point we started identifying an egg as being a chicken egg as opposed to being an egg from another animal. In other words, did the first chicken egg come from a chicken (meaning the chicken came first), or from a proto-chicken (meaning the egg came first)?

A closer variation might be: Which came first, the radio broadcast or the radio broadcaster? Before the radio broadcast and radio broadcaster there was radio and people using radio, but they did not reach a wide public audience. At some point the early small-scale experimental radio use turned into broad utilization, but when and which was earlier on the timeline?


Replies

BMc202011/07/2024

I'd have to go with radio broadcaster. You can make radio waves by touching the poles of a battery together with a wire. BUT, if you don't know you are making radio waves are you still a broadcaster?

show 1 reply