logoalt Hacker News

tra311/07/20242 repliesview on HN

For a YouTuber it's more advantageous to keep switching between various systems to keep generating more YouTube content.

> special physical filing cabinets for notecards

It sounds like you're a bit dismissive of it. The creator of this system Luhmann was a very prolific writer [0] which he credited to this system.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niklas_Luhmann#Note-taking_sys...


Replies

xpe11/07/2024

It would be too coarse-grained to say I'm categorically dismissive of paper-based systems. My views are more nuanced.

Right, I'm aware of Luhmann and Zettelkasten and ZK-inspired systems. I'm glad it works for him and many others.

Still, if one goes down the rabbit holes of ZK and knowledge management systems, you will sooner or later find some videos that leave the realms of productivity and venture into the farcical.

This is important to recognize: "There is a common mistake people [make] when [using] PARA, Zettelkasten, GTD, Bullet Journals [...]. / They assume each system is universal. / These systems were [NOT] built for mass consumption." - 2022 blog post by Zain Rizvi titled "PARA vs. Zettelkasten: The false binary" https://www.zainrizvi.io/blog/para-vs-zettelkasten-the-false...

show 1 reply
xpe11/07/2024

> For a YouTuber it's more advantageous to keep switching between various systems to keep generating more YouTube content.

That's a factor, yes, but before I will grant that it is more (or less) advantageous, we would need to have a much longer conversation. (Right now, however, I'm not particularly interested in running experiments and drawing conclusions about how to best optimize YouTube content creation.)