logoalt Hacker News

burnished11/09/20241 replyview on HN

Harry Potter isnt typically considered scifi because it doesn't critically examine its own premise and because the rules of the universe are yoked to the needs of the plot.


Replies

Retric11/09/2024

> the rules of the universe are yoked to the needs of the plot

It’s common for the rules of the universe to be adapted to fit the plot of random Star Trek episodes.

HP is not considered science fiction because of the trappings of the story. People use spells and enchanted objects for telekinesis, teleportation, and time travel not psychic abilities and technology to do the same things.

> critically examine its own premise

A great deal of science fiction doesn’t do that while plenty of fantasy does.