logoalt Hacker News

Tiling with Three Polygons Is Undecidable

136 pointsby denvaar11/17/202427 commentsview on HN

Comments

xianshou11/20/2024

First you ask how the hell someone could come up with this construction.

Then you realize it was this guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erik_Demaine

show 5 replies
YoumuChan11/20/2024

The author gave a talk on this at Tufts during the FWCG last week. Fascinating talk.

One interesting question from audience was whether the ratio between the largest polygon piece and the smallest piece can be made bounded, as the current construction has unbounded ratio.

whatshisface11/20/2024

That's reminicient of the post correspondence problem. Is the PCP still undecidable for sets of three strings?

show 1 reply
joebergeron11/20/2024

I read the title of this paper and thought to myself, “What are the chances this could be Erik Demaine?”. And sure enough!

bryan011/20/2024

While not proven, is the intuition that this will also be undecideable for 1 and 2 polygon tilings?

romwell11/20/2024

Erik Demaine always has some fun stuff for us.

TeenGirlza1711/20/2024

[flagged]