logoalt Hacker News

Yi Peng 3 crossed both cables C-Lion 1 and BSC at times matching when they broke

588 pointsby perihelions11/20/2024730 commentsview on HN

Comments

nabla911/20/2024

October 2023 there was similar incident where Chinese cargo ship cut Balticonnector cable and EE-S1 cable. Chip named 'Newnew Polar Bear' under Chinese flag and Chinese company Hainan Xin Xin Yang Shipping Co, Ltd. (aka Torgmoll) with CEO named Yelena V. Maksimova, drags anchor in the seabed cutting cables. Chinese investigation claims storm was the reason, but there was no storm, just normal windy autumn weather. The ship just lowered one anchor and dragged it with engines running long time across the seabed until the anchor broke.

These things happen sometimes, ship anchors sometimes damage cables, but not this often and without serious problems in the ship. Russians are attempting plausible deniability.

show 8 replies
thecodemonkey11/20/2024

The Danish defense forces now confirms their presence but they are not providing any other information right now: https://x.com/forsvaretdk/status/1859195509866381402

(This is also a rare English-language tweet from an account that usually only tweets in Danish)

threeseed11/20/2024

And 4 days ago a Russian spy ship was escorted out of Irish waters:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/nov/16/russian-spy-sh...

So definitely seems like a coordinated attempt to destabilise Europe ahead of anticipated peace talks early next year.

show 4 replies
0110001111/20/2024

Title could be a lot more descriptive. Your average reader might scroll on by because that title makes no sense without context.

show 2 replies
A_D_E_P_T11/20/2024

Much more information here: https://gcaptain.com/details-of-baltic-sea-cable-incident-re...

show 1 reply
Hamuko11/20/2024

Yi Peng 3 has been stopped in the Kattegat with Danish navy ships around it for about 11 hours now. Currently HDMS Søløven is anchored right next to it. HDMS Hvidbjørnen was also not too far away before its signal went dark.

nickpp11/20/2024

Also, Russia is sabotaging European satellites:

https://nltimes.nl/2024/11/15/dutch-childrens-channel-outage...

show 1 reply
trhway11/20/2024

>Last ports: Murmansk - Port Said - Luga Bay (never docked, Ust-Luga, Russia)

All the way to Luga and decided to not dock. Large cargo ship pleasure wandering the sea like a yacht.

bobbob192111/20/2024

What I don’t understand - if the yi peng was intentionally trying to damage the FO cables, why would they not spoof or disable their AIS data/broadcast (ship tracking transponder which is the source of this positioning data we see). Anyone have some insight on that?

show 1 reply
TinkersW11/20/2024

This is the 2nd time China did this in that Baltic isn't it? Both times look intentional.. maybe don't allow Chinese ships in the Baltic?

show 2 replies
byearthithatius11/20/2024

YESS!! Finally a bsky link instead of X. Hope this is how it is from now on.

usr110611/20/2024

Looks suspicious, but there were 4 vessels in the area whose transponder signal was lost by public trackers during that night.

It has also been pointed out that this is a location with lively traffic. So if it turns out that is was an anchor (as in the New New Polar Bear case) that's extra suspicious because anchoring in such location is not normal. On the other hand if it were explosives like in the Nord Stream case, they could have been applied also weeks before.

nik_alberta11/20/2024

YI PENG 3 (IMO: 9224984) is a Bulk Carrier and is sailing under the flag of China. Her length overall (LOA) is 225 meters and her width is 32.3 meters. Source: https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/ais/details/ships/shipid:21...

show 1 reply
fjfaase11/20/2024

It looks like that the pilot ship Styrbjoern [1] came along side the Yi Peng 3 today. It traveled from the harbor of Grenaa to the ship and back. It possible that they took some people in for questioning or put a pilot and/or guards on the ship.

[1] https://www.vesselfinder.com/?mmsi=219003826

show 1 reply
a1o11/20/2024

C-Lion -> Sea Lion, but not the IDE from JetBrains.

Gualdrapo11/20/2024

Going from fishing illegally in south american waters to damaging internet cables in Europe.

adverbly11/20/2024

Should be very easy to verify if this was the cause.

All you have to do at this point is go look at the cable near the crossings.

If there is evidence of an anchor hitting the cables in both of these locations then you've got pretty clear proof.

Someone should obviously be checking into this right now. No point speculating until it's confirmed really.

I guess you might still want to board just to find out weather there is any evidence of intent rather than negligence in the case that this is confirmed to be the cause...

show 2 replies
HelloNurse11/20/2024

Crowdsourced military intelligence offers some hope for the future.

hinkley11/20/2024

Do we need to get James Cameron and associates to design a DitchWitch that can operate at 2 miles down? How deep can ship anchors go?

show 1 reply
coriny11/20/2024

Botswana is well in the top half of least-corrupt countries. I suspect you know nothing about Ukraine or Botswana.

rafinha11/20/2024

If a cable goes down, isn't the traffic just re-routed? Don't see the point of intentional damage here.

show 2 replies
selimnairb11/20/2024

I guess WWIV has been on a slow burn for going on three years now.

show 2 replies
mitjam11/20/2024

It was crossing right on time for the interruptions, a Russian officer was on board, it slowed down while crossing, no other ships were slowing down in that area during that time (rulingnout headwinds) - it cannot get much clearer. China is now participating in hybrid warfare against Europe (unless they present stronger evidence against this assumption)

show 6 replies
guerrilla11/20/2024

So what would China's motivation be here?

show 7 replies
a-french-anon11/20/2024

So, when do we know it's not just another operation Northwoods?

show 1 reply
shmerl11/20/2024

How much did Putin pay Xi Jinping for it?

knowitnone11/20/2024

They'll obviously point the finger at another country

jmward0111/20/2024

Completely aside from the cable discussion, I'm glad this was on bsky. I could finally follow the comments in the link again. I hope this trend continues.

show 3 replies
bdjsiqoocwk11/20/2024

I read somewhere that the captain is Russian. What a surprise.

muffwiggler11/21/2024

[flagged]

show 1 reply
halblalaa11/20/2024

[flagged]

1234letshaveatw11/20/2024

[flagged]

matthewfelgate11/20/2024

China will do more and more of this as the USA withdraws from policing the world.

show 1 reply
weweersdfsd11/20/2024

I think it's time for a special navy operation which captures a Russian or Chinese cargo ship every time a cable gets damaged. The ships and their cargo could be then sold to the highest bidder.

show 4 replies
kkfx11/20/2024

Ahem... Cui prodest/cui bono?

What kind of interest Chinese could have to damage such cables? IMVHO ZERO. Also I doubt Russians have interests to do so.

Who could be interested?

- some private company for makes and insurance/the public pay to fix something who need money from the owner for other reasons (like I break on purpose my car to get it repaired for free or at least less money than what it would costing me avoiding the self-sabotage);

- some countries wanting war at all costs trying to create a casus belli to justify the push toward WWIII

- some countries experimenting the resilience of their infra

I fails to see any other potentially interested party.

sedan_baklazhan11/20/2024

So Two Minutes Of Hate towards Russia is over in this aspect? Very Orwellish.

show 1 reply
dfadsadsf11/20/2024

It could be false flag operation to create pretext for NATO/EU to block shipping to Russian ports in Baltic Sea.

Similar to Nordstream destruction in 2022 it could have been either Ukrainians or CIA/NSA. This could be last attempt by current US administration elements to create leverage for the Ukraine before negotiations start.

show 1 reply