logoalt Hacker News

saghmlast Wednesday at 4:15 PM1 replyview on HN

You can't get an arbitrary string into an AST, only ones that can be at parsed correctly. Rejecting the invalid strings that wouldn't make sense to do analysis on is pretty much the same thing that the parent comment is saying to do with regexes, SQL, etc., just as part of the existing compilation that's happening via the type system rather than at runtime.


Replies

skeledrewlast Wednesday at 5:15 PM

Everything can be abstracted away using specialized objects, which can allow for better checking. The Python AST itself is just specialized objects, and it can be extended (but of course with much more work, esp in the analysis tools). There's also this very ingenious - IMO - monstrosity: https://pydong.org/posts/PythonsPreprocessor/. Pick your poison.