logoalt Hacker News

thefaux11/21/20244 repliesview on HN

Sadly, when I was a postdoc, an eminent mathematician I was working under once shared a story that he found amusing that one of his colleagues was once asked a question in the form: "This might be a stupid question, but..." and the response was "There are no stupid questions, only stupid people."

Run into too many people like that, who I daresay are common in the field, and it's easy to see how people become dispirited and give up.


Replies

ckw11/21/2024

That’s a south park quote: https://youtu.be/wWfacULP1o0?si=ddBWXFuQMoxxY-Yu

show 1 reply
Jensson11/21/2024

Isn't that a positive statement, that you can ask questions without worry since they aren't stupid?

show 1 reply
benreesman11/21/2024

I think we can recognize Pauli for his identification of one of the few magic gadgets we accept around spin statistics without accepting his educational philosophy: “Das ist nicht einmal falsch.”

He was right on the nature of the universe, he was wrong on making a better world. I for one forgive him on the basis of time served.

yimmothathird11/21/2024

[dead]