logoalt Hacker News

slowmovintarget11/21/20241 replyview on HN

Force of law is different than fees in a walled garden. Fines are not the same as fees. Every player that does commerce on Apple's infrastructure pays fees to do so. Fines are punishment.


Replies

makeitdouble11/22/2024

While fines should be different, but in practice that line is either blurry or non existent depending on the circumstances.

For instance if Apple had to pay a global total of 2 millions of fine every year for their AppStore policy, it would be rolled in as cost of doing business and they'd keep ignoring the rulings for decades. If Amazon only had minor punishment for breaking AppSore rules they'd do it yesterday.

A binding contract is only as strong as its penalties, and in that regard we can see laws a form of contract and vice versa.

show 1 reply