logoalt Hacker News

aidenn0 • 12/09/2024 • 4 replies • view on HN

Yes we can because if there are no ten-foot tall men, then it is indeed true that "All ten-foot tall men have brown hair"


Replies

aftbit • 12/09/2024

It seems intuitively wrong that you can say "All X are Y" and yet that doesn't imply "At least one X exists".

➕ show 2 replies
out_of_protocol • 12/09/2024

If that is true then liar said truth.

➕ show 2 replies
spencerflem • 12/09/2024

In formal logic, but in regular English that would not be true