logoalt Hacker News

sjm12/09/20245 repliesview on HN

Anyone else find this stuff extremely distasteful? "Disrupting" creativity and art feels like it goes against our humanity.


Replies

quenix12/09/2024

The past few years' innovation in AI has roughly been split into two camps for me.

LLMs -- Awesome and useful. Disruptive, and somewhat dangerous, but probably more good than harm if we do it right.

'Generative art' (i.e. music generation, image generation, video generation) -- Why? Just why?

The 'art' is always good enough to trick most humans at a glance but clearly fake, plastic, and soulless when you look a bit closer. It has instilled somewhat of a paranoia in me when browsing images and genuinely worsened my experience consuming art on the internet overall. I've just recently found out that a jazz mix I found on YouTube and thought was pretty neat is fully AI generated, and the same happens when I browse niche artstyles on Instagram. Don't get me started on what this Sora release will do...

It changed my relationship consuming art online in general. When I see something that looks cool on the surface, my reaction is adversarial, one of suspicion. If it's recent, I default to assuming the piece is AI, and most of the time I don't have time or effort to sleuth the creator down and check. It's only been like a year, and it's already exhausting.

No one asked for AI art. I don't understand why corporations keep pushing it so much.

show 5 replies
ronsor12/09/2024

I'm glad someone else said this. Hopefully we can get rid of that terrible disruptive camera too.

tim33312/09/2024

There's some of that but it produces some cool stuff too. I mean you have these new virtual worlds like this that didn't exist before https://youtu.be/y_4Kv_Xy7vs?t=13

The video there is kind of a combination of human design and AI which produces something beyond that which either would come up with on their own.

ganzuul12/09/2024

It is like an attempt to do psychic battle over the meaning of "disruption".

moralestapia12/09/2024

"And then everyone clapped ..."

There's nothing wrong with technology going forward and this doesn't go against "creativity and art", to the contrary, it will enhance it.

show 1 reply