logoalt Hacker News

bee_rider12/09/20242 repliesview on HN

I think some element of it might be: Shor’s algorithm has been known of for 30 years, and hypothetically could be used to decrypt captured communications, right? So, retroactively I will have been dumb for not having switched to a quantum-resistant scheme. And, dumb in a way that a bunch of academic nerds have been pointing out for decades.

That level of embarrassment is frankly difficult to face. And it would be devastating to the self-image of a bunch of “practical” security gurus.

Therefore any progress must be an illusion. In the real world, the threats are predictable and mistakes don’t slowly snowball into a crisis. See also, infrastructure.


Replies

adastra2212/09/2024

What would you switch to? There hasn’t been post quantum systems to use until very very recently.

bawolff12/10/2024

All you encrypted communication from the 90s (SSL anyways) can probably be decrypted with classical means anyways. 90s SSL was pretty bad.