logoalt Hacker News

imiric12/09/20241 replyview on HN

I don't understand why you see a distinction between models that generate text, and those that generate images, video or audio. They're all digital formats, and the technology itself is fairly agnostic about what it's actually generating.

Can't text also be considered art? There's as much art in poetry, lyrics, novels, scripts, etc. as in other forms of media.

The thing is that the generative tech is out of the bag, and there's no going back. So we'll have to endure the negative effects along with the positive.


Replies

quenix12/09/2024

Simple: I am equally offput when LLMs are used for generating poetry, lyrics, novels, scripts, etc. I don't like it when low-effort generated slop is passed off as art.

I just think that LLMs have genuine use for non-artistic things, which is why I said it's dangerous but may be useful if we play our cards right.

show 3 replies