The host might be selecting between two goats, or might be selecting between a goat and a car. Either way, it doesn't matter because we don't get any additional information about whether our original choice was correct. (To clarify, this applies to the original problem, not the Crawl variant, where we either sometimes get definitive information, or sometimes get no information)
Edit: Furthermore, I don't think that author's solution to the Crawl problem is correct. When the host eliminates a door, either you will get information that says you should switch, and you'll win 100% of the time; or you won't get information, and you should still always switch and win 2/3 of the time.
alt Hacker News
The host might be selecting between two goats, or might be selecting between a goat and a car. Either way, it doesn't matter because we don't get any additional information about whether our original choice was correct. (To clarify, this applies to the original problem, not the Crawl variant, where we either sometimes get definitive information, or sometimes get no information)
Edit: Furthermore, I don't think that author's solution to the Crawl problem is correct. When the host eliminates a door, either you will get information that says you should switch, and you'll win 100% of the time; or you won't get information, and you should still always switch and win 2/3 of the time.