logoalt Hacker News

dtquad12/09/20242 repliesview on HN

Do Americans still want to breakup the big US tech companies like Google? With proper regulation it feels like their positive externalities, like this, is good for humanity.


Replies

skort12/09/2024

The key words here are "proper regulation". In an era where industries have captured governmental bodies, there will likely be no such regulation, and these tech companies will continue to siphon up resources and funnel them to a handful at the top.

A quote from the article is especially ludicrous: > to benefit society by advancing scientific discovery, developing helpful applications, and tackling some of society's greatest challenges

You don't need a quantum computer to do this. We can solve housing and food scarcity today, arguably our greatest challenges. Big tech has been claiming that it's going to solve all of our problems for decades now and it has yet to put up.

If you want this type of technology to be made and do actual good, we need publicly funded research institutions. Tech won't save us.

show 1 reply
0_____012/09/2024

"Proper regulation" may involve breaking companies into pieces such that they cannot dominate industries and deprive the public the option of choosing a different provider for the services they provide. Does an Alphabet subsidiary working on quantum computer research require 90% of search traffic to go through Google? Or for Android handsets to send a really phenomenal amount of telemetry back to the mothership with no real recourse for the average user?