logoalt Hacker News

recursive12/09/20243 repliesview on HN

> OBJECTIVELY pixel art looks incomparably better on CRT monitors

"Objectively" doesn't just mean a thing is a strongly held opinion or even widely held. This seems like a perfect example of a thing that is subjective, not objective. There is no objective metric for measuring the looks of pixel art. Or really any art in general.

Probably most people who care prefer this, but that doesn't mean it's objective.

This probably doesn't contribute to the discussion. But I have a personal peeve about people using the word "objectively" (and "demonstrably") when they really mean "significantly".

Carry on.


Replies

GuB-4212/10/2024

I think the objectivity here is that it is what the artist intended.

Not true anymore for modern pixel art, which is often an art style intended for modern displays, and it is sometimes combined with high resolution images and transforms.

show 4 replies
rifty12/10/2024

Intersubjective is also a word that nicely fills in the ground between subjective and objective.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersubjectivity

MaxGripe12/10/2024

Thank you for pointing that out. I agree that using the word „objectively” in this case was a bit silly, and I apologize for that.