logoalt Hacker News

A UC Santa Cruz professor unearthed the oldest alphabet yet

151 pointsby diodorus01/13/202554 commentsview on HN

Comments

ahazred8ta01/13/2025

The inscribed Umm el-Marra cylinders of northwestern Syria, circa 2400 BC, 500 years before alphabetic writing was derived in Sinai from Egyptian hieratic phonetic writing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Sinaitic_script

show 2 replies
legerdemain01/17/2025

I almost took an introductory course on archeology with Glenn Schwartz, many years ago, but dropped it after the first class. I remember having very different emotional responses to faculty members as a student. Schwartz struck me as elegant, diffident, blue-blooded, and completely disinterested in teaching a bunch of young morons who were just taking the course as a distribution requirement. I'm glad to see that he and his former students are an influential force in this area of study.

show 1 reply
sandworm10101/17/2025

>> I try to keep that in mind when I’m excavating today; scholars of the future are counting on us to leave the best documentation we can.

The answer is to stop digging. It is understood that imaging techniques will eventually be good enough that artifacts may soon be studdied without disturbing the surrounding soil, without destroying all that evidence that future generations might be able to use. Of course that means disrupting the dig-to-museum/auction/television pipeline that funds the field.

show 2 replies
bunupepeurjfh01/17/2025

I hope we will get much more research like this, now when Syria is liberated and has Democratic governors!

show 1 reply
throw73848484801/17/2025

[flagged]

matrix259601/17/2025

[flagged]

show 1 reply
gschizas01/17/2025

As far as I can understand that's not a real alphabet, it's an abjad (consonants only)

show 3 replies
kittikitti01/17/2025

The article states, "symbols on the cylinders could be an early Semitic alphabet" and this is when they lost me. I guess we're just pushing propaganda now.

show 2 replies