logoalt Hacker News

colejohnson66yesterday at 3:46 PM5 repliesview on HN

China doesn't have a constitution like America's.

Edit:

Obviously, China has a constitution, but the freedoms enumerated there are not the same as those in America's. And those that are enumerated are pointless (like North Korea's constitution).

My point is that there's an inherent hypocrisy in saying we're more free than them, but then doing a tit-for-tat retaliatory measure. How can we be more free when we're doing the same things the other side is?


Replies

seanmcdirmidyesterday at 3:55 PM

China has a constitution mostly like America’s, freedom of speech, religion, press are enshrined even more strongly than in the American constitution. What China lacks is judicial review and an independent judiciary, so the constitution has no enforcement mechanism, and so is meaningless. The Chinese government as formed has no interest in rule of law.

show 1 reply
ok123456yesterday at 3:49 PM

So what? If you believe in liberal values (with a small l), like freedom of speech, you lead by example.

show 2 replies
salviatiyesterday at 3:53 PM

Are you aware of this Wikipedia page? [0] I think you should motivate why you believe that what is described in that page should not be called "constitution". Or articulate why you believe that thing does not exist. Or at least motivate your statement. Where does it come from?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_China