logoalt Hacker News

epolanskiyesterday at 4:00 PM6 repliesview on HN

I don't understand the argument here, Tik Tok would maximize their monetization in US but not in other markets?

I don't buy it.


Replies

mywittynameyesterday at 4:09 PM

Think of it like consumer protection laws - Ford has higher safety requirements for the vehicles they sell domestically than they do for those sold in Mexico. Thus, it could be argued that they are not maximizing their monetization of the US market by cutting out expensive safety features that consumers don't pay extra for.

China is wise to have such laws to protect their citizens.

btbuildemyesterday at 4:28 PM

I am a farmer, I grow tomatoes. The ones I sell to large markets, I use pesticides, herbicides, petrochemical fertilizers, etc etc. The ones I grow for my own consumption and for sale at the local market -- those get organic compost and no chemical treatments.

show 1 reply
ineedasernameyesterday at 4:25 PM

Where is TikTok not maximizing monetization? If you mean the GP's comment on China's ban on the algorithm originally used then you are missing a critical aspect of that: It wasn't TikTok's choice to stop or decrease monetization there.

Also, even if they were differently monetizing by region, you are also missing the non-monetary reasons this might happen: Manipulation & propaganda. Even aside from any formal policy by the Chinese govermnent self-censorship by businesses and individuals for anything the Party might not like is very common. Also common is the government dictating the actions a Chinese company may take abroad for these same efforts in influencing foreign opinions.

legitsteryesterday at 4:15 PM

Corporations in China all operate at the behest of "the people" (aka the party). If the government thinks a product is damaging or harmful to society, it can be taken off the market without any legal mechanisms necessary.

show 1 reply
dockdyesterday at 4:12 PM

> algorithm used in the US was apparently banned in China

Sounds like they tried.

tokioyoyoyesterday at 4:26 PM

Frankly, I’m not sure what these comments even mean. Douyin (Chinese TikTok) has the same level of brainrot content, except with some restrictions (political and societal level stuff). Chinese kids are as much addicted to it as Western kids to TikTok/IG, from what I’ve seen.