logoalt Hacker News

amrocha01/21/20251 replyview on HN

If that was the case every scientific paper would be written as socratic dialogue. But it’s not. Because that’s a good format for beginners, but not for science.


Replies

parpfish01/21/2025

the reason the current format exists and is used is because it's very information dense. i think scientific papers would be better if they were socratic dialogues.

but the limitation in publishing a dialogue is that you'd just get to publish one of them and each reader is going to come in with different questions and goals for what they want out of the paper.