logoalt Hacker News

alp1n3_eth01/21/20253 repliesview on HN

Cool writeup with some interesting techniques and approaches!

I'll echo the other comments and say "deanonymization" is stretching the definition of the word, along with "grab the user's location", as it isn't anything near precise. 150 miles is approx. a 2-hour drive on the highway from Atlanta, GA to Augusta, GA. In that radius, there's probably 700,000+ people.

I do think the auto-retrieve attachment feature of Signal is slightly concerning, as for a private messenger I'd expect there to be an option to turn it off (like turning off JS in Tor). I don't know if I'm not looking deep enough, but there doesn't seem to be a feature for that.

Signal appears to take a useful-by-default approach that balances privacy and ease-of-use in order to encourage adoption by the masses, I'd assume most people that are really concerned are hardening Signal, similar to what is in this guide: https://www.privacyguides.org/articles/2022/07/07/signal-con... . They've always recommended a VPN / proxy + a modification of settings for more high-security scenarios.

Caching isn't going anywhere, and neither is CloudFlare. The DoSing days of old in P2P multiplayer lobbies with exposed IPs seemed to carry more of a threat than this, CloudFlare's response seems to be the best out of the 3. Caching sensitive information is never recommended and the onus is on the application doing the communicating to tell their CDN / middle-service to not cache specific items.


Replies

giancarlostoro01/21/2025

> "deanonymization" is stretching the definition of the word, along with "grab the user's location", as it isn't anything near precise.

You'd think so, but you would be surprised how quickly this adds up to other details people share, like "oh I just drove 15 minutes to get Starbucks" or something to that effect, small things that eventually add up to a precise location over time.

show 1 reply
vel0city01/21/2025

You can disable the auto-download. Settings > Data and storage > Media auto-download, you can choose what to auto download for mobile data/wifi/roaming.

show 3 replies
why_only_1501/21/2025

Random unrelated point: in a 100km radius circle between Atlanta and Augusta there are ~2,000,000 people (calculated using https://www.tomforth.co.uk/circlepopulations/ )

show 1 reply